The Small Details in the Archives and the Meaning of a Non-existent Photography from the Home of a Stationer in Helsingborg

  • Karin Gustavsson Lund University
Keywords: Field work, Knowledge production, Archives, Photography, Punctum and Studium, Urban history

Abstract

This article describes and problematizes the skills that are used when researching analogue archives. The article deals with the process that operates when a researcher finds small details in archival records that makes it possible to generate a story. Whether it is skill or luck that enables one to find the phenomena that create meaning is also discussed. The empirical example is fetched from the “Swedish Town project” that was initiated with the aim to write a new kind of urban history in the 1940s by Swedish art historian Gregor Paulsson. The researcher Börje Hanssen conducted field work in the city of Helsingborg in southern Sweden during the summers in 1942, 1943 and 1944. The “Swedish Town”-project explored urban history through both traditional sources such as archives, but also by interviews with contemporary town inhabitants and photographs. In the article we meet both Hanssen and some of his interviewees, and his working methods, his texts and some photographs are being analyzed. Börje Hanssen later became an influential ethnologist and in this article we encounter him in the beginning of his career. In order to examine the role played by one small detail in a large amount of material, and how such a detail can influence the researcher’s inter- pretations, Roland Barthes concepts of punctum and studium are used in the article, in order to create meaning out of small, everyday and often seemingly insignificant phenomena. Punctum and studium are fruitful analytical tools, not only in analyzing photographs, which was Barthes original use of the concept but also in other contexts, in this case archival records. The article thus discusses when a detail becomes the punctum that changes the researcher’s mindset and enables new knowledge to be produced.

References

Archives

Nordiska museets arkiv, / Nordic museum
Börje Hanssens personarkiv / Private archive of Börje Hanssen
Gregor Paulssons samling / Gregor Paulsson’s collection

Uppsala universitetsbibliotek / University Library of Uppsala
Gregor Paulssons personarkiv / Private archive of Gregor Paulsson

Literature

Barthes, Roland (1981): Camera Lucida: Reflecions on Photography. New York: Hill and Wang.

Burke, Peter (2001): Eyewitnessing: The Use of Images as Historical Evidence. London: Reaktion Books.

Ekström, Simon (2017): Humrarna och evigheten. Kulturhistoriska essäer om konsumtion, begär och död. Göteborg: Makadam.

Dahlgren, Anders (2016): "The Svensk stad (Swedish Town) Project-Architectural History in Action. Konsthistorisk tidskrift/Journal of Art History, 85:1, 76-84. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00233609.2015.1116023
https://doi.org/10.1080/00233609.2015.1116023

Dahlgren, Anders (2018): "Fullständigt otillförlitlig, men absolut oumbärlig". En historiografisk undersökning av projektet Svensk stad, doctoral dissertation. Göteborg University. https://gupea.ub.gu.se/handle/2077/54585

Engstöm, Elin (2015): Eketorps veckningar. Hur arkeologi formar tid, rum och kön, doctoral dissertation. Stockholm University.

Ernst, Wolfgang (2015): Stirrings in the archives: order from disorder. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

Grünberger, Tulla (1981): "Arkivmaterialet till Svensk stad". Thomas Hall & Ingrid Hammarström (eds.) Perspektiv på Svensk stad. Staden som forskningsobjekt 1950 1980. En skrift från projektet Svensk stadsmiljö, byggande och boende under de senaste hundra åren. Stockholm: Akademilitt., 144-155.

Gustafsson Reinius, Lotten (2009): "Sensing through white gloves: On Congolese objects in Swedish Collections". In: The Senses & Society, Vol. 04, no 01. 75-97. http://eds.b.ebscohost.com/eds/detail/detail?vid=0&sid=522cd676-854e-4600-9d35-5c0cef4ce2ca%40sessionmgr120&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWRzLWxpdmUmc2Nvc- GU9c2l0ZQ%3d%3d#AN=38698569&db=a9h

Gustavsson, Karin (2014): Returning to the Archive in Search of Everyday Practices in Fieldwork. Ethnologia Europaea, Journal of European Ethnology. Vol 44:2. 61-75.

Gustavsson, Karin (2017): Kunskap ur tomrum. Närläsning som etnologisk metod. Lars-Eric Jönsson, & Fredrik Nilsson (eds.) Kulturhistoria. En etnologisk metodbok. Lund: Institutionen för kulturvetenskaper, Lunds universitet. https://lup.lub.lu.se/search/publication/97af2335-280c-47c5-b7ab-eb1dcb4e6d54

Gustavsson, Karin (2019): "Platsen för industrialismens drama. Om Söder i Helsingborg och bokverket Svensk stad". Pål Brunnström & Ragnhild Claesson (ed). Creating the city: Identity, Memory and Participation. Conference proceeding. Malmö, Malmö University, 161-179.

Gustavsson, Karin (2020): "What Börje Hanssen saw: About photographic imagery and knowledge of a town". Peter Aronsson, Andrej Slávik & Birgitta Svensson (eds). Images in History / History in Images. Towards an (audio)visual historiography. Kungl. Vitterhets Historie och Antikvitets Akademien Series: Konferenser 99, 59-72.

Götselius, Tomas (2008): "Åter till arkivet". Foreword. Wolfgang Ernst. Sorlet från arkivet. Ordning ur oordning. Göteborg: Glänta.

Lennartsson, Rebecka (2014): "Arkivetnografi eller reflektioner över en tappad biljett". Kulturella Perspektiv 2014:3, 8-19.

Löfgren, Orvar (1996): "Ett ämne söker sin väg". Billy Ehn & Orvar Löfgren (eds.) Vardagslivets etnologi. Reflektioner kring en kulturvetenskap. Stockholm: Natur och kultur, 13-87.

Löfgren, Orvar (1997). "Scenes from a troubled marriage: Swedish ethnology and material culture studies". Journal of material culture. 1997(2):1, 95-113.
https://doi.org/10.1177/135918359700200105

Myrberg Burström, Nanouschka (2012): "A Study of Punctuality: Using typo-chronology as Barthes' studium and punctum". Nanouschka Myrberg Burström & Fredrik Fahlander (eds.) Matters of Scale: Processes and courses of events in the past and the present. Stockholms universitets förlag, 75-89.

Nilsson, Bo G. (1996): Folkhemmets arbetarminnen. En undersökning av de historiska och diskursiva villkoren för svenska arbetares levnadsskildringar, doctoral dissertation, Stockholm University.

Stoklund, Bjarne (1980): "Börje Hanssen 1917-1979". Ethnologia Scandinavica. A Journal for Nordic Ethnology 1980, 155-157.

Stoklund, Bjarne (2003): "Ethnology and vernacular architecture. Revisiting a

classical field of study". Ethnologia Scandinavica vol 33, 5-20.

Svensson, Birgitta (2012). Varför etnologi?:En ämnesintroduktion för nya studenter. 1. uppl. Lund: Studentlitteratur.

Published
2020-05-26
Section
Archive and Methods